Yes, they are that much better. No, it's not worth the gong show. At least not for me!So I have never had a springer, are they really that much better than fresh-caught Puget Sound Salmon? I looked into doing it last year, but I was feeling a bit intimidated to jump into springer fishing madness without any experience. Especially given the way you troll with or against the river and current at bouy 10.
Columbia River spring Chinook is the very best salmon I have ever eaten. Period. If there is better salmon out there, I don't know about it. Puget Sound Chinook are nearly all of Green River hatchery fall Chinook origin. Fresh in from ocean feeding they are OK, but that's as good as they get, and they get worse as table fare the more days they are since their last ocean meal.So I have never had a springer, are they really that much better than fresh-caught Puget Sound Salmon? I looked into doing it last year, but I was feeling a bit intimidated to jump into springer fishing madness without any experience. Especially given the way you troll with or against the river and current at bouy 10.
The Tule Stock is the ESA listed stock too right? So that keeps the fishery open longer too right?Columbia River spring Chinook is the very best salmon I have ever eaten. Period. If there is better salmon out there, I don't know about it. Puget Sound Chinook are nearly all of Green River hatchery fall Chinook origin. Fresh in from ocean feeding they are OK, but that's as good as they get, and they get worse as table fare the more days they are since their last ocean meal.
I have found lower Columbia (B-10) coho to be excellent eating, and Gray's Harbor coho too. There are too many places I haven't salmon fished that I can't comment on their table quality.
I'm also a snob for Fraser sockeye, the earlier the better. Bristol Bay AK sockeye are good too, but not as good as the Fraser fish that have longer migration runs and time between freshwater entry and spawn timing - that affects the lipid content of the flesh. (That is also what makes spring Chinook better eating than their fall counterparts. However, B-10 Up River Bright Chinook are fantastic table fare, just not as good as springers. And B-10 Tule Chinook are throw backs in my boat; we don't want them.)
I don't do much meat fishing, but when I do it usually involves a herring or anchovy as bait.
YEah the tule stock is the listed one. They tend to come in earlier, so at least starting last year, they are starting to push the opening date back a bit to let more get through, which lowers the encounters. Hopefully they keep that up.The Tule Stock is the ESA listed stock too right? So that keeps the fishery open longer too right?
Yes, the wild Tules are ESA listed, but it's a management cluster fuck. The wild Tules are offspring of naturally spawning hatchery Tules. They will never recover because Tule spawning habitat is forever degraded and compromised. IMO it's a wasted effort. The Tule listing has shut down the sport season when there were URBs left to catch, but as Evan mentions, OR and WA have changed the season a bit to give anglers a bit more fishing time on URBs.The Tule Stock is the ESA listed stock too right? So that keeps the fishery open longer too right?
Yeah, the whole tule management thing always left me frustrated for the reasons you mention.Yes, the wild Tules are ESA listed, but it's a management cluster fuck. The wild Tules are offspring of naturally spawning hatchery Tules. They will never recover because Tule spawning habitat is forever degraded and compromised. IMO it's a wasted effort. The Tule listing has shut down the sport season when there were URBs left to catch, but as Evan mentions, OR and WA have changed the season a bit to give anglers a bit more fishing time on URBs.
Exactly!!!The effort some put in to tying flies is the effort I put in to my culinary endeavors
Yes, the wild Tules are ESA listed, but it's a management cluster fuck. The wild Tules are offspring of naturally spawning hatchery Tules. They will never recover because Tule spawning habitat is forever degraded and compromised. IMO it's a wasted effort.
Puget Sound tributaries are seriously degraded, but many, if not most, can support naturally self-sustaining Chinook populations. Except the Stilly; it's toast unfortunately. Lower Columbia tribs that formerly hosted wild Tules are so modified, with upper reaches being all commercial timber tree farms. The siltation of redds is likely to prevent them from ever producing enough smolts to generate a spawner : recruit ratio of 1.Sounds similar to a lot of Puget Sound chinook stocks.