Saw those tomahawk ribeye steaks yesterday at Costco for $9.99/lb, so I bought a pack. (Aside - never saw ribeye steaks cut like that in my life until just a few years ago. I wonder why they do that since the meat cut off the "handle" must just go into stew meat or something instead of beef ribs. Not to mention that the long tomahawk handle makes it hard to fit the steak onto my BBQ.) The steaks are cut so thick I'm not sure the best way to cook them. A steak is usually seared, cooked hot and sorta' fast so it's brown on the outside and rare or medium rare inside. Well, 6 minutes per side made for a nice brown exterior, but it was still raw and cold inside. Ended up going an additional 18 minutes as the charcoal was burning down to get the inside sorta' in between rare and medium rare. How are you supposed to cook a steak that is cut 2 - 2 1/2" thick? It was delicious BTW, and we'll have leftover for lunch or dinner today.
Im not sure what kind of grill you have, but after searing put the cover on and check internal temp with an instant read thermometer 120-125Saw those tomahawk ribeye steaks yesterday at Costco for $9.99/lb, so I bought a pack. (Aside - never saw ribeye steaks cut like that in my life until just a few years ago. I wonder why they do that since the meat cut off the "handle" must just go into stew meat or something instead of beef ribs. Not to mention that the long tomahawk handle makes it hard to fit the steak onto my BBQ.) The steaks are cut so thick I'm not sure the best way to cook them. A steak is usually seared, cooked hot and sorta' fast so it's brown on the outside and rare or medium rare inside. Well, 6 minutes per side made for a nice brown exterior, but it was still raw and cold inside. Ended up going an additional 18 minutes as the charcoal was burning down to get the inside sorta' in between rare and medium rare. How are you supposed to cook a steak that is cut 2 - 2 1/2" thick? It was delicious BTW, and we'll have leftover for lunch or dinner today.
They are basically a fancy mini rib roast. Sear and then indirect heat till the proper internal temp. Like every everyone else says. They would be very charred if cooked like a normal steak that thick.Saw those tomahawk ribeye steaks yesterday at Costco for $9.99/lb, so I bought a pack. (Aside - never saw ribeye steaks cut like that in my life until just a few years ago. I wonder why they do that since the meat cut off the "handle" must just go into stew meat or something instead of beef ribs. Not to mention that the long tomahawk handle makes it hard to fit the steak onto my BBQ.) The steaks are cut so thick I'm not sure the best way to cook them. A steak is usually seared, cooked hot and sorta' fast so it's brown on the outside and rare or medium rare inside. Well, 6 minutes per side made for a nice brown exterior, but it was still raw and cold inside. Ended up going an additional 18 minutes as the charcoal was burning down to get the inside sorta' in between rare and medium rare. How are you supposed to cook a steak that is cut 2 - 2 1/2" thick? It was delicious BTW, and we'll have leftover for lunch or dinner today.
Since there is just two of us, I have a Weber Smokey Joe, pretty small as charcoal grills go. And that's why it was hard to fit that handle on the grill under the hood cover. I knew it would take some "art" regarding how many briquets and when in the burn cycle to cook it. Like Tictoc posted above, I couldn't leave it too long on charcoal producing their peak heat without charring the hell out of the outside in order to get the desired doneness inside. I think I timed it pretty well for the steak, but we started the mushrooms in a frying pan on the stove too soon and had to leave them in the hot/warm pan while the steak finished cooking.Im not sure what kind of grill you have, but after searing put the cover on and check internal temp with an instant read thermometer 120-125
I like to go the opposite way: low and slow to temp (120 for me), rest 20 minutes, then hard sear and serve immediatelyThey are basically a fancy mini rib roast. Sear and then indirect heat till the proper internal temp. Like every everyone else says. They would be very charred if cooked like a normal steak that thick.
Same here - reverse sear the thick stuff and they come out very evenly cooked w/o having to deal with a sous vide.I like to go the opposite way: low and slow to temp (120 for me), rest 20 minutes, then hard sear and serve immediately